Peanut Butter Jelly Cookie Cups

Golden peanut butter cookie cups with indented centers filled with red strawberry jam and small white cream cheese piped swirl. This recipe brings the contrasting textures together in a small dessert made for sharing.

Jump to ingredients · Jump to recipe method

Yield: 24 mini cups · Prep: 25 minutes · Cook: 12 minutes · Rest/chill: 30 minutes

Table of Contents

Ingredients · Before you start · Directions · Tips · Storage · FAQ

Ingredients

Ingredient and amount
100 g unsalted butter, softened
100 g smooth peanut butter
100 g light brown sugar
1 large egg
1 tsp vanilla
160 g all-purpose flour
1/2 tsp baking soda
1/4 tsp salt
120 g thick strawberry jam
100 g cream cheese, softened
25 g powdered sugar

Before You Start

Use regular smooth peanut butter rather than runny natural peanut butter for predictable cookie texture.

Directions

Step 1

Heat oven to 180°C conventional/160°C fan and grease a 24-hole mini muffin tin.

Step 2

Beat butter, peanut butter and brown sugar creamy. Beat in egg and vanilla.

Step 3

Stir flour, baking soda and salt together and mix into the dough. Divide among the 24 wells, pressing lightly.

Step 4

Bake 10–12 minutes until edges are golden. Immediately press an indentation in each with the back of a teaspoon. Cool 10 minutes in tin, then transfer carefully to a rack.

Step 5

Beat cream cheese with powdered sugar. Once cups are cold, add 1 tsp jam to each and a small piped swirl of cream cheese.

Step 6

Chill 30 minutes to firm the topping.

Tips for the Best Texture

Use regular smooth peanut butter rather than runny natural peanut butter for predictable cookie texture.

Measure ingredients before beginning. Oven temperatures are for conventional ovens unless the fan setting is given; use visual doneness cues alongside the timing.

Storage

Refrigerate filled cups covered up to 3 days; unfilled cookie cups freeze well for 1 month.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I prepare this dessert ahead?

Refrigerate filled cups covered up to 3 days; unfilled cookie cups freeze well for 1 month.

What should I check before serving?

Use regular smooth peanut butter rather than runny natural peanut butter for predictable cookie texture.